No AI detector can tell you who wrote a text. It can only say that the writing resembles what its training data labelled "AI" or "human". That is a guess, and it fails in predictable ways.
Detectors guess, they do not know
Ordinary text carries no hidden proof of where it came from. A detector looks at patterns such as word choice and sentence shape. Human writers and AI tools overlap a lot, especially in formal writing, so every detector makes two kinds of mistakes: it flags some human text, and it misses some AI text.
Who gets flagged unfairly
- Non-native English writers. A 2023 study by Stanford researchers found that several popular detectors labelled writing by non-native English speakers as AI-generated far more often than writing by native speakers, likely because simpler wording looks "predictable".
- Formulaic writing. Cover letters, abstracts and lab reports follow a fixed shape on purpose.
- Short texts. A few sentences are not enough evidence for anyone.
- Heavily edited text. Grammar tools and rewrites push writing toward the same smooth style.
Even the makers have backed away
In July 2023 OpenAI shut down its own AI text classifier because of its low rate of accuracy. Detector companies today publish their own benchmarks, but no one has a method that is reliable enough to be the sole evidence against a person.
If you are flagged
- Stay calm and keep your drafts, notes and version history. Google Docs and Word both record how a document grew.
- Explain your process: where the ideas came from, what you changed, what sources you used.
- Ask what evidence was used besides a detector score, and ask for a human review.
- Point to the research above. A score alone is a weak basis for a serious decision.
What this means for SentenceBase
SentenceBase does not issue verdicts. It shows which phrases sound automated, with a score that is an estimate, so you can improve your own writing. On our small test set it catches most AI samples and wrongly flags a few percent of human ones, and it does worse on casual writing, non-native English and short texts. Read the details on how it works, try the free checker on your own text, and please never treat a score as proof.